It appears that your cart is currently empty
Understanding Equine Sarcoids: A Guide for Horse Owners
Steve Fennell
Understanding Equine Sarcoids: A Guide for Horse Owners
1.0 What is an Equine Sarcoid? An Introduction for Owners
An equine sarcoid is the most common type of skin tumor found in horses. While the word "tumor" can be alarming, it's strategically important to understand what a sarcoid is—and what it is not. Sarcoids are not internally metastatic, meaning they will not spread to your horse's lungs, liver, or other organs. However, they are known to be "locally aggressive," capable of invading and damaging the skin and underlying tissues where they appear. This locally destructive nature, combined with their unpredictable behavior, makes them a significant welfare and management concern for any horse owner.
At their core, sarcoids are complex skin growths triggered by a virus. They often begin as a small, harmless-looking patch or lump and can remain unchanged for years before suddenly growing rapidly and spreading. They frequently appear in multiples; it's more common for an affected horse to have several sarcoids than just one. In fact, a study of horses in the UK found that affected individuals had an average of 20–30 lesions each. Understanding their nature is the first step toward effective management and making informed decisions with your veterinarian.
Key Facts at a Glance
• Who is affected? Sarcoids can affect any horse, regardless of breed, age, or sex. However, they are most often diagnosed in young adult horses between one and seven years old. Certain breeds and bloodlines also appear to have a higher genetic susceptibility, with studies showing a higher incidence in breeds like Arabians and Quarter Horses.
• Where do they appear? While a sarcoid can show up anywhere on the body, common locations include the sensitive skin around the eyes, ears, and mouth; in the girth and saddle regions; on the limbs; and in the groin and genital areas.
• Why are they a problem? Sarcoids can become a serious issue when they grow in locations that interfere with tack, such as the girth or bridle path. They can become large, painful, bleed, and develop secondary infections, significantly impacting the horse's comfort, use, and overall quality of life.
The visual appearance of a sarcoid can vary dramatically, which is why a proper veterinary diagnosis is so critical. This diversity has led to a classification system that helps veterinarians predict a sarcoid's behavior and choose the most appropriate treatment.
2.0 The Six Faces of Sarcoids: Identifying the Different Types
Sarcoids are not a "one-size-fits-all" diagnosis. They present in six distinct forms, and a single horse can have multiple types at once. Understanding these different classifications is strategically important because the type of sarcoid often influences its behavior, aggressiveness, and the veterinarian's recommended treatment plan.
• Occult Sarcoid This type appears as a flat, roughly circular area of hairless, slightly thickened, and scaly gray skin. Occult sarcoids are often mistaken for ringworm or a simple rub mark. While they can remain stable for a long time, they are known to become aggressive and grow rapidly if irritated by rubbing, injury, or even a biopsy.
• Verrucous Sarcoid Often described as having a "wart-like" or "cauliflower" texture, this type is a dry, crusty, and flaky growth. The surface is often gray or brown and irregular. Verrucous sarcoids commonly appear on the face, groin, and in the armpit area and can cover large patches of skin. They might ulcerate, forming raw patches, if they get traumatized.
• Nodular Sarcoid These are firm, well-defined spherical lumps that form under the skin, which can often move under the skin. They can be single or appear in clusters, sometimes feeling like a "bunch of grapes." Nodular sarcoids are common on the eyelids, in the groin, and along the legs. The overlying skin may be normal, or the nodule can eventually break through and ulcerate.
• Fibroblastic Sarcoid This is an aggressive, fleshy mass that strongly resembles "proud flesh." Fibroblastic sarcoids are often raw-looking, bleed very easily, and can grow rapidly. This type frequently develops at the site of a previous wound or injury, which may have been the entry point for the causative virus.
• Mixed Sarcoid As the name suggests, this type combines the features of two or more other types in a single lesion. For example, a sarcoid might have a flat occult area, a warty verrucous edge, and a nodular component underneath. Mixed sarcoids are common in long-standing cases or in lesions that have been previously irritated or partially treated.
• Malevolent Sarcoid This is the rarest but most aggressive form. Malevolent sarcoids spread extensively through the skin and along the body's lymphatic vessels, creating cords of tumor tissue and connected nodules. Due to its invasive nature, this type is extremely difficult to treat.
A Critical Note on Diagnosis
Sarcoids are masters of disguise and can mimic a wide range of other skin conditions, from fungal infections and warts to proud flesh. For this reason, professional veterinary evaluation is essential. While a biopsy can provide a definitive diagnosis, veterinarians are often cautious about taking a tissue sample from a suspected sarcoid. The trauma of a biopsy can, in some cases, "stir up the lesion," triggering a previously stable sarcoid to become much more aggressive and grow faster. Consequently, diagnosis is often made based on the sarcoid's distinct clinical appearance and location. This cautious approach highlights the complexity of managing these reactive tumors.
3.0 The Culprits: Unpacking the Causes and Risk Factors
The development of equine sarcoids is not due to a single cause but rather a "perfect storm" of viral infection and genetic susceptibility. Understanding this dual-factor cause is strategically important for owners, as it helps explain why a particular horse was affected and provides a framework for reducing risk.
The Viral Trigger
The primary culprit behind sarcoids is the Bovine Papillomavirus (BPV). This is a wart virus that originates in cattle, where it typically causes only minor skin warts. However, when BPV infects a horse's skin cells, it can trigger the uncontrolled growth that leads to sarcoid tumors. The DNA of BPV is found in the vast majority of equine sarcoids, confirming its central role in the disease.
Transmission and Genetic Links
Sarcoids are not contagious through casual contact like a flu. Instead, transmission most likely occurs when biting flies, such as stable flies or houseflies, carry viral particles from infected cattle or from an existing sarcoid on another horse and deposit them onto broken skin. This explains why sarcoids often appear at the site of previous wounds or scars.
Crucially, not every horse exposed to BPV will develop sarcoids. Genetic predisposition plays a key role. Research has shown that certain breeds and family bloodlines are more susceptible to developing these tumors. A horse must have the right genetic makeup to be vulnerable to the virus's tumor-causing effects. This is why you may see one horse in a herd develop multiple sarcoids while its pasture-mates remain completely unaffected, despite being in the same environment.
Key Takeaways on Causation
• Primary Cause: A combination of infection with the Bovine Papillomavirus (BPV) and an individual horse's genetic susceptibility.
• Transmission: The virus is likely spread by biting flies and through the contamination of open wounds, not by direct horse-to-horse contact.
• Individual Susceptibility: A horse's genetic makeup is a critical factor; exposure to the virus alone is not enough to cause a sarcoid.
With a diagnosis confirmed and the cause understood, owners face a critical decision: what to do next?
4.0 The Critical Decision: To Treat, Monitor, or Leave Alone?
The unpredictable nature of equine sarcoids makes the decision of how to proceed after a diagnosis a crucial strategic conversation to have with your veterinarian. You must balance the risks of intervention—which can sometimes anger a dormant lesion—against the risks of inaction, which can allow a small problem to become a much larger one.
The Case for Early Treatment
In most situations, veterinarians recommend treating sarcoids as early as possible. As the Liphook Equine Hospital notes, “Treatment should be started as early as possible as lesions won’t get better, but they may get worse.” The reasoning is clear: sarcoids very rarely resolve on their own. Left untreated, most will eventually grow larger, multiply, or transition to a more aggressive type. Small, early-stage lesions are far easier, less expensive, and more likely to be treated successfully than large, established tumors. Furthermore, there is often greater urgency if the horse is young, as younger horses’ sarcoids tend to be more aggressive.
When "Watchful Waiting" is an Option
There are specific scenarios where monitoring a sarcoid may be an appropriate initial step. For example, a single, small, stable occult sarcoid in a location where it does not interfere with tack or movement may be a candidate for "watchful waiting." However, this monitoring must be active and done in close consultation with your veterinarian. This involves taking regular photographs and measurements to track any changes. If the lesion begins to grow, change texture, or multiply, the plan must shift immediately to active treatment.
The Dangers of "DIY" Interference
A firm line must be drawn between professional treatment and "do-it-yourself" remedies. Under no circumstances should an owner attempt to cut, burn, tie off, or apply unproven home remedies to a sarcoid. Inappropriate interference is one of the most common reasons a dormant sarcoid "explodes" into a rapidly growing, aggressive fibroblastic tumor. Even a seemingly minor irritation can provoke a dramatic and negative response.
Ultimately, the decision-making framework should be guided by professional advice. Consult your veterinarian, lean towards treating any sarcoid that is growing or located in a problematic area, and strictly avoid any form of unguided interference.
5.0 A Realistic Guide to Veterinary Treatment Options
It is essential for owners to approach sarcoid treatment with realistic expectations. There is no single "magic bullet" cure. Treatment often requires persistence, patience, and a multi-faceted approach, as a therapy that works for one sarcoid may not work for another. Reported success rates for most established treatments fall within the 40-70% range for complete remission, and it is crucial to understand that recurrence is common.
Your veterinarian will recommend a course of action based on the sarcoid's type, size, location, and your horse's individual circumstances. Here are some of the primary treatment options available:
• Topical Chemotherapy Creams (e.g., "Liverpool Cream") These are prescription-only creams containing cytotoxic (cell-killing) agents that are applied directly to the sarcoid. The treatment process can look dramatic; the sarcoid will become very inflamed, swollen, and sore before it turns black and eventually sloughs off. Owners should be prepared for this process, as pain relief and stall rest might be needed. While the process can be uncomfortable, these creams can be highly effective.
• Immunotherapy (e.g., BCG Injections) This approach stimulates the horse's own immune system to recognize and attack the tumor cells. The most common method involves injecting the sarcoid with BCG, a vaccine for tuberculosis. This is a particularly useful option for sarcoids located around the eye, where surgery is risky. The treatment typically requires a series of injections and must be done by a vet, as there is a small risk of a severe allergic reaction.
• Surgical Removal (Excision, Laser, Ligation) Surgically cutting out a sarcoid must be done with wide margins, as microscopic tumor "fingers" often extend into the surrounding healthy tissue. If any cells are left behind, recurrence is highly likely. For this reason, surgery is often combined with other therapies. Laser surgery may reduce the risk of spreading cells. A large removal can result in a wound that can’t be sutured closed and has to heal by second intention, which can be lengthy. Ligation (banding) is only suitable for specific stalked sarcoids.
• Cryotherapy (Freezing) This technique uses liquid nitrogen to freeze and destroy the tumor cells. It is most effective on small, superficial sarcoids and often requires multiple freeze-thaw cycles. However, recurrence rates can be high, and it can cause scarring and damage to the surrounding healthy skin.
• Radiation (Brachytherapy) Considered a "gold standard" for its high success rates (often near 100% for suitable cases), radiation involves implanting radioactive material directly into the tumor. It is particularly effective for difficult-to-treat sarcoids. However, this option is expensive, requires hospitalization at a specialized referral center, and is not widely available.
• Injectable Chemotherapy (e.g., Cisplatin) Chemotherapy drugs like cisplatin can be injected directly into the sarcoid or implanted as slow-release beads. This method is valuable for nodular and fibroblastic sarcoids and is often used after a large tumor has been surgically "debulked" to kill any remaining cancer cells.
• Topical Antiviral Cream (Acyclovir) This antiviral cream (commonly used for human cold sores) can be effective against flat occult and verrucous sarcoids. A study showed that daily application led to complete regression in 68% of treated sarcoids, with no recurrences reported. It is an inexpensive, safe option that may be recommended by your vet, though it can take 1-2+ months to see the result.
Other and Emerging Therapies
• Electrochemotherapy: A newer technique that uses electrical pulses to increase the absorption of an injected chemotherapy drug into tumor cells.
• Photodynamic Therapy: A treatment involving a light-activated drug that destroys sarcoid tissue.
• Gene Therapy: An experimental approach being researched that aims to "turn off" the viral genes responsible for tumor growth.
Even after a treatment appears successful, microscopic tumor cells can remain. It is critical to understand that excised sarcoids often regrow more aggressively within 6 months if not all tumor cells were removed. Long-term monitoring of the treatment site is essential.
6.0 Fact vs. Fiction: Navigating Sarcoid Myths and Remedies
The frustrating and persistent nature of sarcoids has given rise to countless folk remedies and myths. While the desire for a simple, inexpensive solution is understandable, it's strategically critical to avoid unproven treatments. As experts at Equine Medical Solutions warn, "Using the wrong treatment often results in the sarcoid becoming a more aggressive tumour." Experimenting can waste valuable time and may turn a manageable problem into a severe one.
• Herbal Supplements (Turmeric, Echinacea) Despite anecdotal claims, there is no scientific evidence that feeding supplements like turmeric or echinacea can cure or shrink equine sarcoids. As renowned equine scientist Dr. David Marlin has noted, there is a complete lack of research on turmeric as a sarcoid treatment. While these herbs are unlikely to cause harm, they should not be relied upon as a primary therapy.
• Homeopathic Remedies (e.g., Thuja) There is no reliable scientific proof that homeopathic preparations are effective against sarcoids. Because these tumors are so unpredictable, any perceived success is likely coincidental or due to the rare occurrence of spontaneous regression, not the remedy itself.
• "Bloodroot Salves" (e.g., Xxterra) This is not a myth, but a powerful caustic agent that requires extreme caution. Products containing bloodroot extract chemically burn away the tumor tissue, and there is some evidence for their use; a small study reported about a 93% success rate. However, these salves cause significant inflammation and pain and can easily damage healthy surrounding skin. They should only be used under strict veterinary guidance.
• The Myth of "Ignoring It" While spontaneous regression is known to happen, it is exceptionally rare. The vast majority of sarcoids will not go away on their own. In fact, they are far more likely to grow, multiply, and become a much larger problem if ignored.
Your veterinarian is your most important partner in managing sarcoids. By choosing evidence-based treatments over unproven remedies, you give your horse the best possible chance for a successful outcome.
7.0 Prognosis and Prevention: A Long-Term View
When facing a sarcoid diagnosis, it's important to maintain a balanced perspective on the long-term outlook. The good news is that sarcoids are not life-threatening in the way that metastatic cancers are; they will not spread to internal organs. However, the prognosis for a complete, permanent cure must be guarded due to the high rate of recurrence.
Managing Expectations for the Future
With vigilant management and a strong partnership with a veterinarian, most horses with sarcoids live long, comfortable, and useful lives. The impact on a horse's quality of life depends heavily on the sarcoid's type, location, and how aggressively it is managed. A sarcoid in a difficult location, such as on an eyelid, or an aggressive malevolent type, carries a more complicated prognosis. The goal of management is to control the lesions so they remain a minor issue rather than a major health problem.
Strategies for Risk Reduction
While there is no way to guarantee prevention, especially in a genetically predisposed horse, you can take practical steps to reduce the risk of new sarcoids developing:
• Rigorous Fly Control: Use fly sheets, masks, and effective repellents, especially during warmer months. Good manure management will also help reduce the fly population in your horse's environment.
• Proper Wound Care: Promptly clean and cover any new wounds to prevent flies from landing on them and potentially introducing the virus.
• Good Hygiene and Biosecurity: Avoid using the same girths or grooming kit on a sarcoid horse and then on others without disinfecting, especially if any lesions are ulcerated.
• Regular Health Checks: Groom your horse daily and run your hands over their entire body to detect any new or suspicious lumps early. Catching a sarcoid when it is the size of a pea provides a much better chance of successful treatment than waiting until it is the size of a golf ball.
While equine sarcoids are a frustrating and unpredictable challenge, a knowledgeable owner working in close partnership with their veterinarian provides the best path to successful management. Persistence is key. Modern veterinary treatments, though imperfect, offer a powerful toolkit that can control or eliminate most sarcoids. By staying vigilant and committed to evidence-based care, you can ensure your horse's long-term health, comfort, and well-being.
0 comments